Now's your chance to spy on Google
Posted: Tuesday, November 10 2009 at 06:00 am CT by Bob Sullivan
If you only have time to visit one new Web site this week, make it the new Google dashboard. Last week, the search engine behemoth announced the new feature, which helps Web users keep track of all the ways Google keeps track of them.
Visiting this single page gives Googlers centralized access to privacy settings on all the various Google applications -- Gmail, Calendar, Google Docs, YouTube, etc. That's important, because you might not realize that you opened a YouTube account four years ago and divulged your age or zip code -- and that now that information could be available to all other Google products, or even to other Google users.
"The scale and level of detail of the Dashboard is unprecedented, and we're delighted to be the first Internet company to offer this — and we hope it will become the standard," Google wrote in its announcement.
You might think you already have a good grasp on what information Google has collected about you. But given Google's dominance in search, and its ever-expanding reach into Web services, it's stunning to see all that information in one place. Click, and I'll bet you'll be surprised.
Larry Ponemon, who runs privacy research firm The Ponemon Institute, said he thought Google Dashboard was a solid step forward for Web privacy rights.
"I'm pretty impressed with it," he said. "It's always interesting to see what a company knows about you. ... It does create more transparency for users."
As the search giant continues to push into more and more Internet fields, Google's privacy policies have increasingly been the target of government scrutiny, both here and abroad. Last year, the European Data Protection Working Party -- part of the European Commission -- published an opinion that search engines like Google should not store consumer information for more than six months.
Limited access
There are some severe limitations to Google's Dashboard, however. Most important: it doesn't provide any new access to Google’s data mines. Dashboard simply provides a single Web page that pulls all its services under one umbrella and makes it easier to find privacy settings and stored information. That's a good thing, but it does not provide new insights or new protections for Google users who were already careful with their settings.
The tool is also limited to information gathered on users when logged in to Google. It doesn’t give consumers access to information that might be tied to individual consumers in other ways -- such as searches associated with individual computer IP address or cookies. That means it falls short of being a true privacy tool, according to privacy rights advocacy group Consumer Watchdog.
"The dashboard gives the appearance of control without the actual ability to prevent Google from tracking you and delivering you to its marketers,” said John M. Simpson, a spokesman for the nonprofit organization. "It doesn't reveal anything about what is at the heart of what I call Google's 'black box' -- what is associated with your computer's IP address."
Google addresses this concern on a page titled “Is this everything?” linked from the Dashboard. There, the firm explains that cookies and IP address tracking are intentionally kept separate from Google login accounts, so the information is not displayed on the Dashboard.
“We anonymize this … data by removing part of the IP address (after 9 months) and cookie information (after 18 months),” the firm says.
But Simpson said failure to include that information on the Dashboard tool severely limits its usefulness.
“A true privacy control would enable you to delete all that information and opt out,” he said.
Simpson also criticized Google for not including another new privacy setting on the dashboard page -- Google's "Ad Preferences" tool.
Google tracks users, places them into categories based on interests (such as 'current events' or 'science') and serves up targeted advertisements near search results based on those categories. The firm now makes the list of categories available to each user on its Web site, and it’s another page all Web users should visit.
Users can add or remove categories, or they can opt out of the system entirely.
"They have been citing that as another privacy initiative, so why isn't that part of the Dashboard?" Simpson asked.
It's not easy to find Dashboard on Google's home page. Users must glance atop the page and click on settings, then Google Account Settings, and then "View data stored with this account." Direct links to google.com/dashboard also work.
Still, even Simpson concludes that Google's dashboard makes the firms privacy efforts "better than any of the other online providers."
Most are complacent
It's unclear how many users will find Google Dashboard useful, or will spend time tweaking their privacy settings.
Ponemon, the privacy researcher, said studies consistently show that while 70 percent of Americans say they care deeply about privacy issues (the other 30 percent are considered "privacy complacent") only 8 percent of the population cares enough to actually change their behavior out of privacy concerns. So while most people say they are uncomfortable that a supermarket has their home phone number, only 8 percent decline to sign up for a loyalty card -- or take some other step, such as lying on an application -- out of privacy concerns.
Still, tools like Google Dashboard might help change that -- or at least get more people talking and thinking about privacy issues, Ponemon said. He thinks every Web user should visit the Google Dashboard and click around, just to get a broad sense of the information that's been collected by the firm.
"It's pretty helpful for people to see it," he said. "People really might be surprised that Google has this much information."
Become a Red Tape Chronicles Facebook fan
Confessions of a credit card telemarketer
EMAIL THIS
TRACKBACKS
Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do no appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451b0aa69e20120a66bb806970b
advertisement
BUY BOB SULLIVAN'S NEW BOOK
Bob Sullivan's new book unmasks hundreds of hidden fees and offers step-by-step instructions on how to fight back. Order it here.
Also available as an audio book.
Red Tape Video
RED TAPE ARCHIVES
This article is about as useful as tits on a bull and less interesting than watching grass grow.
Shame on you Bob.
For a writer who's work is usually thought provoking, informative, relevant, interesting and useful, this is one screams "I'm phoning it in folks."
You're better than this....
MikeS, St. Louis, MO. (Sent Nov 17, 2009 5:37:19 PM)
Surprised? Not me. I'm sure every other company collects information when you sign up with any of their services. Why wouldn't they? At least Google is saying, "Here - take a look at what's out there," for your information.
Erin Lee (Sent Nov 10, 2009 4:36:39 PM)
The advertising industry business model was a result of the limitations of publishing and communications technology. The internet changes that underlying technology from broadcast to bidirectional. The result is that publishers no longer hold a privileged position as the gateway to the consumer’s attention. Publishers and service providers are trying to become value added channels by going beyond selling attention to becoming data merchants as well. However, these intermediaries are reselling data that is not their property, and are violating privacy putting consumers at risk. Consumers are also becoming savvy to the value of their attention and data and the fact that they do not have to relinquish this value to an intermediary who’s “value add” is a commodity and whose financial interests are at odds with their individual privacy and financial interests.
Efforts like this dashboard are distractions. Google giving me access to my own information which they have clandestinely pilfered from me – that’s value?
John Smith, Everywhere, CA (Sent Nov 10, 2009 3:53:41 PM)
I am surprised.
How can I just plain opt out or quit? Should I delete every Google account of all kinds?
lowguy (Sent Nov 10, 2009 12:50:06 PM)
I really like msnbc-but its a dead zone for me on the net-you wont let me share content with twitter or facebook-so while I watch the TV network-this is a waste of time for me...just an opinion-I would have loved to extend the opportunity to bring traffic here by linking it to twitter-but hey-you must know what yer doin....
Warren Sanford Sacramento, California (Sent Nov 10, 2009 11:24:10 AM)
come on... not only is the fact that google collects marketing data news from years ago... Google dashboard is last week...
If you want to be anonymous on the internet "opting out" is not going to solve anything... If you don't think that your ISP or Place of work or school store your online traffic history for a period of time you are delusional...
Great article! BTW
P
Pietro, Boston, MA (Sent Nov 10, 2009 10:13:54 AM)
SEND A COMMENT
PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others. Firms mentioned in our comment area are welcome to add their own comments.